This ain’t no “Secret.”
“Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” icon Whitney Leavitt is currently starring as Roxie Hart in “Chicago” at Broadway’s Ambassador Theatre up until May 3*.
Come Monday, April 6, she’ll be joined by her “Dancing With The Stars” partner and Broadway vet Mark Ballas (who will inherit the role of lawyer Billy Flynn) for a month’s worth of performances.
If you’d like to see the buzzy pair live, tickets are available for all of their shows together.
At the time of publication, the lowest price we could find on seats for any one co-production of theirs was $152 including fees on StubHub.
Other shows of theirs start anywhere from $153 to $167 including fees.
As a quick reminder, the Tony Award-winning musical “Chicago” tells the tale of Roxie Hart, a ’20s housewife, who offs her paramour and persuades her husband to take the fall.
“Roxie is not afraid to say what she wants, and I can relate to that,” Leavitt said about the character she’s inhabited since early February. “But I don’t love how she went about it, obviously.”
According to critics, the 32-year-old Utah native has allegedly breathed some fresh air into the long-running production, which has been going strong on the Great White Way since 1996.
“Her voice, slightly breathy yet shockingly earnest, mixed confidence with curiosity,” Fortune Herald noted in a review.
“Even seasoned theatergoers were occasionally taken aback by her timing, which paused long enough between lines to allow an audience response to develop naturally. It felt untrained but instinctively timed. Not perfectly Broadway. But refreshingly human.”
In regards to Ballas, he previously portrayed Frankie Valli in the last Broadway “Jersey Boys” shows in 2016-17. More recently, the 39-year-old dancer/choreographer/musician played Charlie Prince in “Kinky Boots” from September to November 2018.
“Ballas, known for his skill as a professional dancer, is very charismatic and hits all of the right notes at the most crucial moments, including on his biggest song, Frankie’s solo smash ‘Can’t Take My Eyes Off Of You,’” Onstage Blog wrote.
For more information, our team has everything you need to know and more about “Chicago” on Broadway with Whitney Leavitt and Mark Ballas below.
*Leavitt’s has a number of “Chicago” shows without Ballas. They take place March 10-15 and March 23 through April 5.
“Chicago” tickets
Inventory to see “Chicago” live on Broadway is available on all verified ticketing sites.
We recommend checking out StubHub, Ticketmaster and Vivid Seats to find the seats that makes the most sense for you.
Best “Chicago” ticket prices with Whitney Leavitt and Mark Ballas
As of now, there are only 17 shows with seats going for under $160 including fees for Whitney Leavitt and Mark Ballas’ scheduled performances from April 6 through May 3 at the Ambassador Theatre.
Based on our findings, here are the 17 show dates with tickets under $160 including fees in chronological order by date:
| “Chicago” dates | StubHub prices start at |
|---|---|
| Monday, April 6 7 p.m. |
$155 (including fees) |
| Sunday, April 12 2 p.m. |
$154 (including fees) |
| Sunday, April 12 7 p.m. |
$155 (including fees) |
| Thursday, April 16 7 p.m. |
$154 (including fees) |
| Friday, April 17 8 p.m. |
$154 (including fees) |
| Saturday, April 18 8 p.m. |
$153 (including fees) |
| Sunday, April 19 7 p.m. |
$154 (including fees) |
| Monday, April 20 7 p.m. |
$159 (including fees) |
| Thursday, April 23 7 p.m. |
$153 (including fees) |
| Friday, April 24 8 p.m. |
$153 (including fees) |
| Saturday, April 25 2:30 p.m. |
$159 (including fees) |
| Saturday, April 25 8 p.m. |
$154 (including fees) |
| Thursday, April 30 7 p.m. |
$152 (including fees) |
| Saturday, May 2 2:30 p.m. |
$154 (including fees) |
| Saturday, May 2 8 p.m. |
$153 (including fees) |
| Sunday, May 3 2 p.m. |
$154 (including fees) |
| Sunday, May 3 7 p.m. |
$154 (including fees) |
“Chicago” cast
Leavitt and Ballas have the benefit of taking the stage with Broadway vets and silver screen stars every night of their brief run.
Sophie Carmen-Jones (Hulu’s “Kiss of the Spider Woman”) co-stars with Leavitt as Velma Kelly; she’s inhabited the role since February 2025.
Rounding out the cast are stage stars Greg Hildreth (Netflix’s “Maestro”), Jacqueline B. Arnold (“Smash” on Broadway”) and Mykal Kilgore (who you may have seen in “Jesus Christ Superstar Live!”).
The entire cast and their accompanying bios can be found here.
Huge Broadway musicals
Many fan-favorite crowd pleasers are still delighting audiences far and wide this year.
Here are just five of our favorites you won’t want to miss IRL.
• “Wicked”
• “Harry Potter and the Cursed Child”
Love live music too? Take a look at our list of all the biggest concert tours in 2026 to find the show of your dreams.
This article was written by Matt Levy, New York Post live events reporter. Levy stays up-to-date on all the latest tour announcements from your favorite musical artists and comedians, as well as Broadway openings, sporting events and more live shows – and finds great ticket prices online. Since he started his tenure at the Post in 2022, Levy has reviewed a Bruce Springsteen concert and interviewed Melissa Villaseñor of SNL fame, to name a few. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change.
